Looking for the Perfect Cloth Diaper Detergent?

Selecting the right cloth diaper detergent can go a long way to making your cloth diapering experience a piece of cake.  So, if there's anywhere you should spend some time doing research, it's in the area of detergents, washing routines, and hard water.  Don't listen to just any old advice, but spend some time to understand how detergents work, and why washing routines can be anything but routine!



Our goal with this article is to provide you with more information about cloth diaper detergents, as well as links to some more detailed articles you can refer to for more information if you want a deeper understanding.Washing cloth diapers can seem daunting because there is a ton of conflicting information out there on the internet about the best way to wash cloth diapers, and more cloth diaper detergent brands than you can imagine!


Cloth diapers are designed to absorb urine. It's important that they are clean, because residues from detergent or other laundry products can reduce absorbency or even cause diapers to repel, and urine residues will cause stinky diapers!  Clean diapers should not smell.  If your diapers are not absorbing or have a smell that will knock you over, this is an indicator that you need to adjust your wash routine.  If you have a good wash routine, you should never need to strip your cloth diapers. 



Choosing the Right Detergent for Cloth Diapers

When selecting a cloth diaper detergent, you should always choose one that is free of:

  1. Fabric softeners
  2. Stain guards and other stain protection, which will cause repelling


Most cloth diaper manufacturers also recommend avoiding detergents that contain:

  • Phosphates - Note: this isn't a major concern since most countries have legislated phasing out of phosphates from detergents and many mainstream detergents including Tide and Purex are already formulated to be phosphate free.  Most boutique detergents were originally formulated without phosphates.
  • Enzymes (see note below)
  • Optical Brighteners (whitening agents) (see note below)
  • Perfumes, fragrances, and dyes
  • Alcohol


A Note About Enzymes

About half of commercial laundry detergents are free of enzymes, and they are seldom added to boutique cloth diaper detergents.  
Enzyme sensitivities are a sensitive subject!  Many cloth diaper websites recommend against detergents containing enzymes because they are bad for sensitive skin.  I have read countless forum posts and blog articles written by mothers claim that detergents with enzymes have irritated their babies skin, and if your baby has sensitive skin, you may simply wish to choose a detergent without enzymes to avoid any potential issues.


However, according to a detailed and well-researched post on EcoNuts website, any adverse effects of  enzymes on the skin are simply a myth.  The article does go on to say that detergents containing enzymes can actually be hard on your diaper fabrics, and especially wool.  The article suggests that "to prolong the life of your fabrics and clothes, you should choose an enzyme-free detergent and instead utilize enzyme stain removers where needed."  You can read more here.


A Note About Optical Brighteners

Optical Brighteners (OBAs) or Fluorescent Whitening Agents (FWAs) are added to products, such as  laundry soaps, detergents, or cleaning agents. Their purpose, as described in this article, is to "adsorb to fabrics or materials during the washing or cleaning process. When illuminated by ultraviolet light they fluoresce and make products and fabrics appear brighter."


According to detergent manufacturer Seventh Generation, "they don't have anything to do with getting things clean -- they're only added to detergents to make us think our laundry is brighter and whiter than it really is."


There are some suggestions that optical brighteners may be harmful to the environment or your baby's skin, but I found little evidence from government or research sites other than environmental organizations to substantiate this.  Nor could I find anything that would support that optical brighteners reduce the absorbency of your fabrics.  Tide, and many other detergents that contain optical brighteners, work very well for many cloth diapering families.


That said, many families choose not to take risks with unnecessary ingredients.  If you wish to avoid optical brighteners, most boutique detergent manufacturers (i.e., cloth diaper detergent makers) avoid them.  There are also some commercially available brands:  the US Military requires that all army combat uniforms be laundered with detergents free from optical brighteners, and they suggest the following detergents to be suitable: Bold powder, Cheer Liquid, Cheer powder, All powder, Surf powder, and Woolite. 


Soaps vs. Detergents

You should also avoid soap-based detergents. Soaps are created from natural ingredients that can react with the minerals that are found in your water and cause films or residues to occur in your fabric.

You can read more about the reaction between soaps and hard water here.



What are the Best Cloth Diaper Detergents?

Nellies laundry detergent for cloth diapers

There is no single perfect cloth diaper detergent that will work for everyone.


There are two main considerations that you will need to think about when selecting a laundry detergent for your cloth diapers:

  1. Personal choice: you yourself must consider how important it is for you to choose an all-natural formulation and which ingredients you would like to avoid.  These types of detergents can come with a higher cost
  2. The type of water you are using to wash your diapers:  The hardness of your water will also have a major impact on the detergent that will work for you.  Hard water reduces the effectiveness of your detergent, making it harder for your diapers to get clean.  If you have hard water, read this.


If you have soft water, almost any line of cloth diaper friendly detergents will work.  Some of the most widely recommended detergents for cloth diapers are:

  • Nellie's Laundry Soda
  • Rockin Green
  • Laundry Tarts
  • Allens Naturally - available in both powder and liquid format
  • Country Save
  • And countless other brands

All of the detergents above have been extensively tested on cloth diapers.  Our favorite is Nellies, which my sisters and I (who all have very different water types) have used with good success.  You can read more about our experience and why we love it our full review of Nellies Laundry Soda.


That doesn't mean that you can't use a commercial detergent.  While these detergents aren't completely free of all of the "should be avoided" products, many families report success with Tide and other popular supermarket detergent brands. 


If you have hard water (and the majority of North American households do!), you will most likely need to boost your cloth diaper wash routine to get your diapers clean.  You may need to increase the dose of your detergent, add a water softening agent to make your detergent more effective, or select a different detergent (such as Tide or another mainstream offering).  After a lot of research into detergents, water softening additives, and dosages, we suggest that you take the time to read our full our article on hard water and cloth diapers to find a cloth diaper wash routine and detergent that works.



Why are there So Many Detergent Choices?

Shopping for detergents can be a frustrating experience at the best of times! But it can be even worse when you're shopping for cloth diaper detergent!


It may take some trial and error to find the perfect detergent because detergent effectiveness will depend on:

  • Whether you use a high efficiency (HE) or top-load washing machine
  • How hard or soft your water is, and whether there are other minerals presentYour washing routine
  • The style of diapers you use. Flat cloth diapers will be the easiest to clean, while all-in-ones will be harder to rinse free.
  • The type of fabric you use. Cotton will usually rinse clean easier than microfiber or fleeces.


Not all cloth diaper detergents will work for all cloth diapers, so you may need to experiment to find one that works for you.



How much detergent should I use?

how much cloth diaper detergent should I use?


Please keep in mind that using the right amount of detergent is important to avoid issues later on!


You may have heard that you should use only a minuscule amount of detergent to wash cloth diapers.  According to a detailed article on cloth diaper laundering by Wazoodle, a large US-based manufacturer of cloth diaper textiles, "The practice of low detergent dosing is something that has been created in the [cloth diaper] industry by people who don't understand how water, detergent and textiles interact in the wash.  There is no good reason for low doses; it is simply a wrong practice."


For best results, you should start with the detergent manufacturer's dosage recommendation, and then adjust down for very soft water or up for hard water.


NOTE:  If you choose to use a supermarket brand of detergent, keep in mind that most supermarket detergent manufacturers have moved to 2x and 3x concentrated formulas, which mean that the amount of detergent required has been reduced.  Make sure to look at the dose recommendation on the package and fill your scoop or cup to the appropriate line!


If you don't use enough detergent, you will end up with urine residues - this causes stinky diapers. To much detergent will lead to detergent residues, which can reduce absorbency.  If either happens you will need to remove this build-up to get your diapers back to normal. Read more about this process in our article on stripping cloth diapers.



Where Can I Buy Cloth Diaper Detergents?

While it can be hard to find a great cloth diaper detergent in your supermarket, the brands identified above are carried by many online cloth diaper retailers.  Some of the brands are also available from Amazon and Costco.  If you have a local specialty baby store, you'll probably find that they will carry one or more brands of cloth diaper detergent as well.  Local stores are a great place to buy cloth diaper detergents, because they have usually been tested by other local families who have similar water conditions to you.  If it works for them, it will likely work for you too!



Can I Use Bleach on Cloth Diapers?

Bleach is used to kill bacteria and viruses, but isn't necessary for most cloth diaper routines. Cloth diapers usually need only be rinsed clean with detergent, not deeply sanitized with bleach. However, if your baby has had a virus or bacterial infection, it's always best to consult with your pediatrician to find out if your cloth diapers will need further disinfection.


Keep in mind that many cloth diaper manufacturer warranties are void if you use bleach products, since they have been known to damage the fabrics (especially PUL, which can delaminate).  Even if manufacturers do approve of chlorine bleach, it is generally only needed as a remedial step for diapers that need to be disinfected, and not part of a regular washing routine.


If you are concerned about your diaper warranty, please look into the information provided by your diaper manufacturer.  Here are a few links to some of the big brands:

If you are interested in a brand that isn't on this list, I used the Google search "[brand name] bleach recommendation".


There are 2 types of bleach available today:

  1. Chlorine bleach weakens fabric fibers and causes them to break down
  2. Oxygen bleach, which has a very different chemical make-up from chlorine bleach, is safe for fabric, and isn't harmful to the environment. Some manufacturers and parents swear by an occasional wash with oxygen bleach (such as Oxy-Clean) to keep their diapers looking brand new.


Diaper Wreckers shows the impact of chlorine vs. oxygen bleach on a bamboo insert.


There are also alternative disinfectants that can be used for many infections, including sunlight, grapefruit seed extract, and vinegar.  I plan to write a more detailed article on bleach and alternatives in the future!



Further Reading

I encourage you to dig deeper into the topic of cloth diaper detergents if you still have questions.  Here are a few of the articles I found helpful:


Author's Note to the Critics:   I don't claim to be a laundry expert, but I have scoured countless blog and forum posts, websites, and even scientific articles in an attempt to bring together reliable information about cloth diaper detergents.  My goal with this page is to help those that are getting started to find trustworthy information that will help them select an effective detergent when they start out so that they can avoid issues later on.  If you do see any material in this article that you feel is incorrect or misleading, please contact me directly with information you feel will help me make the appropriate updates to this article.  



Conclusion

Choosing the right cloth diaper detergent for you does take a bit of homework.  Take the time to understand how detergents work and how to get the right dose.  I hope that the information in this article will help you select a detergent and dose that will work for you, so you can avoid the infamous stinky, smelly diaper problems!


For questions or comments on cloth diaper detergents, head over to our Facebook page and leave us a note!



More in Our Laundry Series

  1. Overcoming Hard Water:  An Understanding of How to Get Your Cloth Diapers Clean
  2. Choosing a Detergent
  3. How to Store Your Diapers Until Wash Day
  4. The Basic Laundry Routine
  5. Wool Dryer Balls
  6. Off on the Right Foot:  Prepping Your New Diapers
  7. The Stinkies:  How to Strip Cloth Diapers
  8. 10 Helpful Laundry Tips
  9. Diaper Service: Cloth Diapers Without the Laundry


Go to top of Cloth Diaper Detergents



Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links.  I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.” For more information, see our Disclaimer and Copyright.





Popular Posts

Cleaning Cloth Diapers: How to Overcome Hard Water
6 Reasons Why I Don't Miss Disposables
Inserts: Understanding Absorbency Options
Make a Wet Bag in 20 Minutes or Less
The Ultimate Guide to Repairing Cloth Diapers



For more cloth diaper laundry information, return to Washing Cloth Diapers.


At Thinking About Cloth Diapers, we offer reliable, up-to-date cloth diaper research to save you time so you can get on with the other things you want to do.


Return to Thinking About Cloth Diapers homepage.



Sponsor Love